E-readers v. books

All the buzz around the nook, the kindle, and other e-reading devices gave me pause to ponder if they might make such a great gift after all. I've been a fan of the "affordances" of paper in the office and at home, despite being something of a techie, but I'm certainly not alone in my suspicious take on "the future of the book":

full article here:
All I Want for Christmas is an E-Reader?


Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.


Someone, and maybe it has to be me, needs to seriously and thoroughly address the digital rights management issues around e-readers and e-book files. Everyone discusses the sentimental quality of print book reading, without addressing these critical business and property rights concerns. E-books are 90% of the cost of print books, but unlike print you can't 1) trade; 2) sell; or 3) share your purchase; and 4) in the case of Amazon's Kindle e-book files, publishers can retrieve that file from you anytime. See this article, which I first thought was a hoax, because of the book involved (Orwell's 1984) and how preposterous it was, what the publisher, along with Amazon, did - http://www.nytimes.com/2009/07/18/technology/companies/18amazon.html

These are the very same issues that plague people who download MP3s, and yet, for some reason, they accept the inconvenience of authorizing / deauthorizing computers, and other restrictions that I listed above. Electronic files, for software, music and now books have turned the very notion of property rights - I own this, and can do with it what I wish, not only on to its head, but has made it a dirty phrase. "What", the companies exclaim, "you want to share? Resell? Trade? Merge? Your own electronic property! Then you are a thief!"

I hope that readers, unlike music fans so far, will resist the transition to a mostly electronic format, until 1) open digital rights management - ie, free buy, sell, trade and share; and 2) no proprietary formats, are the norm.

Until then, I'll gladly pay the extra 10% and actually own what I own.

Syndicate content